Trump: A Retrospective

It’s now ten years since Donald Trump won the 2016 American presidential election. This victory was predicted by few, but VJM Publishing was one of those few. We correctly foresaw that rising discontent with the state of America would propel an “outsider” candidate to power. This article looks back on the decade since then.

Trump may not have really been an outsider, but he was portrayed as one, and it was easy to believe. His opponent in 2016, Hillary Clinton, had been Barack Obama’s Secretary of State, and she oversaw the murder of Muammar Gaddafi and the destruction of Libya. This followed on from the Afghanistan and Iraq Wars instigated by the previous Republican President, George W Bush. In this context, Trump’s promise for no new wars looked appealing. He was presented as a respite from the warmongering.

This promise did not eventuate. Trump initially seemed like he would be different to the rest of the American Establishment, but the Iran War earlier this year ended those hopes. This is widely considered the main reason for why young Americans, i.e. the ones who would have to fight if the Iran War got out of control, swung heavily away from the Republican side in the recent midterm elections.

Trump’s approval ratings are generally poor: only 32% of Americans think he’s doing a good job per one recent poll. His highest approval rating was only 49%, much lower than any previous president.

A core tenet of Trump’s election platform was restricting immigration. But he didn’t really do this. In 2021, 13.6% of American residents were foreign-born. By 2024 that was 14.8%. Several commentators have pointed out that immigration flows in 2025 and 2026 are sharply reduced from previous years; there may even be net negative migration in America right now. But the damage has already been done. Many American cities are today unrecognisable, and Americans have given up on the hope of mass deportations.

Trump did absolutely nothing about the banking cartel that runs America. Neither did he do anything about money printing. When he came to power in 2017, the American national debt was about $20 trillion. As of today, the debt is over $40 trillion. Joe Biden is responsible for a big chunk of that increase, but $11 trillion of it happened under Trump. The American financial strategy, ever since Dick Cheney said “deficits don’t matter,” has been to print money to finance everything, and to let our future children pay it back. Trump didn’t change this.

A consequence of these failures is the skyrocketing price of housing. Since 2016, the average house price in America has increased by about a third. By itself, this wouldn’t be too much of a problem (wages have also increased in that time), but the average mortgage rate was 3.65% in 2016 and this has climbed to 6.72% today. Grok calculates that the cost of servicing the average mortgage in America has jumped from $860 per month in 2016 to $2240 per month at time of writing.

Related to this is the collapse of American fertility. By 2023, American fertility rates had collapsed to 1.62 children per woman, about a quarter below replacement rates. In 2016, when Trump first came to power, it was 1.82 children per woman, still below replacement rates but by only half the margin of today. As people give up on life for themselves, they also give up on life for offspring.

Trump has kept the unemployment rate low, which is perhaps the best that can be said about his economic management, but the jobs don’t pay enough.

Most embarrassing for Trump have been some of the atrocious appointments he has made, like the buffoonish Secretary of War Pete Hegseth and the clearly insane White House spiritual adviser Paula White, who once claimed that “To say no to President Trump would be saying no to God.”

Aside from this general slide into misery, and the broken promises about warmongering, Trump came to power on a raft of other promises that were not kept.

Many underplay the importance of the Epstein Files saga, but it strikes at the heart of confidence in the American political system. We were told that a list of Epstein’s clients was on Attorney General Pam Bondi’s desk waiting to be released, yet now Trump says that it’s time to move on from the Epstein files. This cynical attitude almost feels like Trump has been mocking the American people through blatantly not keeping his promises.

Trump’s promise to “Drain the Swamp” didn’t come close to being fulfilled. No serious effort was made to expel the Deep State from the corridors of American power. Many early Trump supporters eventually concluded that The Swamp must have had some dirt on him, and they threatened to reveal it unless he went along with them. Only this could explain why Trump got into power and then just sat there.

In Trump’s defence, the reality is that most things are out of his control. He is not Jupiter. Not even Augustus Caesar was able to increase the birth rate. But in the final analysis, Trump lived up to very few of his promises.

Most of the promise of the Trump Presidency lay in nationalism. His entire platform was Make America Great Again. The reasoning was that America had spent too much time, energy and money trying to improve an ungrateful world, and it was time to pull back and focus on Americans. He didn’t do this. Maybe he laid a few speed bumps for the Globalist Hate Machine, but it rolled on anyway.

*

For more of VJM’s ideas, see his work on other platforms!
For even more of VJM’s ideas, buy one of his books!

*

If you enjoyed reading this piece, buy a compilation of our best pieces from previous years!

Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2024-25
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2023
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2022
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2021
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2020
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2019
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2018
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2017

Perhaps the worst impact Trump has had is through making people more cynical about politics.

VJMP Reads: Aristotle’s Politics VI

This reading continues from here.

In Book VI of Politics, Aristotle discusses how democracies and oligarchies can be constituted to endure. Appealing to a sense of the epic, he writes that “The maintenance of a constitution is what really matters.” The most important measure of a democracy or an oligarchy is not how democratic or oligarchical it is, but for how long it can endure.

Democracy, for Aristotle, is inspired by liberty and the desire for liberty (in this regard Aristotle follows Plato): “The underlying principle of the democratic form of constitution is liberty.”

Democracy has several characteristics. The first is election of officers by all, and from all (this is very similar to the modern conception of democracy). The second is the system of all ruling over each, and each, in his turn, over all. The third is appointing by lot to all offices (lotteries were considered more democratic than voting). The fourth is no property qualification for voting or office. The fifth is no office ever held twice by the same people. The sixth is that the tenure of every office should be brief. The seventh is that courts should be composed of all (not just the upper classes). The eighth is that the popular assembly should be sovereign in all matters.

Also like Plato, Aristotle had a high degree of contempt for democracy. He writes that “while oligarchy is characterised by good birth, wealth and culture, the attributes of democracy would appear to be the very opposite – low birth, poverty and vulgarity.” The idea that democracy is rule by lowest common denominator is ancient. The poor are considered dishonourable: “The masses covet profits more than they covet honours.”

The poor promote democracy in their self interest, reasoning that they can secure their interest through taking power: “The weaker are always anxious for equality and justice. The strong pay no heed to either.” In this context, it can be noted that the modern obsession with equality comes from the bottom of society, explaining the vulgar ways it is pushed.

Despite his criticisms of democracy, Aristotle also had reservations about putting too much power in too few hands: “the power to act at will leaves no defence against the evil that is present in every human being”. He also echoes the modern left when he writes that “Poverty is the cause of the defects of democracy.”

As mentioned previously, Aristotle considered democracy, oligarchy and tyranny to be perverted forms of constitutions. This means that the tactics used by some are applicable to others: “All the measures adopted by tyrants may equally be regarded as congenial to democracy.”

*

For more of VJM’s ideas, see his work on other platforms!
For even more of VJM’s ideas, buy one of his books!

*

If you enjoyed reading this piece, buy a compilation of our best pieces from previous years!

Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2024-25
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2023
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2022
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2021
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2020
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2019
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2018
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2017

The Alt Centrist Approach To Generational Relations

For many centuries, generational relations have been simple. Older people worked to take care of the young, and then when the young grew up they took care of the old. Everyone had a turn at helping and at being helped. This all ended with the Boomers. The Boomers took their turn at being helped, and then ripped up the social contract to run society exclusively for their short-term benefit.

The old systems worked on the basis that the elderly would teach the young wisdom. The problem today is that today’s elderly have little wisdom to teach. The elderly of previous generations had survived wars and great depressions, and taught the following generations not to trust authorities and to think for themselves. The Boomers, by contrast, teach that if it wasn’t true, they wouldn’t be allowed to say it on television.

The approach of the Establishment up until now has been to offer old people the fattest and most luxurious pensions possible. Pensioners in France receive more money on average than the average working-age adult. So when it comes to distributive justice, Boomers take the lion’s share, and the people that actually build and maintain society live off the scraps. This has led to stagnation, a violation of the First Rejection.

The Boomer-first approach also violates the First Acceptance by leading to revolution. Long-term societal order is predicated on fairness; without fairness, the disadvantaged become resentful and begin to support an overthrow of the existing social order. So far, television, smartphones, pharmaceuticals and cheap protein have combined to limit revolutionary fervour. But the housing situation has become so bad in the West that true hatred of Boomers is starting to appear in the hearts of Gen Z and some Millennials.

The alt centrist does not believe in impoverishing old people. But they must not have luxuries at the expense of the young. This is why the alternative centrist approach to generational relations involves cutting pensions to the level of unemployed young people. No state pension should be higher than the lowest unemployment benefit.

The idea that old people have been promised luxury pensions, and therefore they have the right to force young people to pay for them, is utterly rejected. The idea that the pension age is a ‘finish line’ at which people can stop contributing and get waited on by the young is also rejected. The universal basic income (see The Alt Centrist Approach To Welfare) puts an upper limit on the extent of the welfare burden that old people can impose on the young.

The healthcare burden would be limited as well. The alternative centrist approach is to rapidly euthanise anyone old and sick enough to become a significant expense. In the past, dementia patients were kept alive in the hope some miracle cure would be found. This was not a major problem because other conditions killed the vast majority of people before they could develop dementia. It is believed that global costs of dementia will hit USD2.8 trillion by 2030. In New Zealand alone the costs are billions of dollars annually.

All this misery and expense would be prevented by an alternative centrist government under the Fourth Rejection. It is cruel to keep dementia patients alive in the vain hope of a miracle cure, and thus they would be euthanised.

Already those aged 65 or over consume half of all healthcare expenditure in New Zealand. The cited report claims “The average 85 year old uses 16 times more healthcare than the average 40 year old.” Much of this expense goes to cancer treatment, which can keep old people alive for decades beyond their natural life span. The alternative centrist opposes spending billions on lost causes. Thus we support euthanasia for old people riddled with cancer.

The combined cost of pensions and healthcare represent a titanic burden on younger generations. The alternative centrist would remove it and let younger people breathe freely.

Generational relations have chiefly been destroyed by the unwillingness of Boomers to have children, and to contribute to raising them. If there are no younger generations, there are no generational relations. Birth rates collapsed when the Boomers hit adulthood and decided to drink booze instead of raise families. Ultimately, today’s problem with generational relations all come down to monumental selfishness on the part of Boomers. Boomers are a Cluster B personality disorder on the scale of an entire generation.

This selfishness is all downstream of the philosophical approach of Boomers, which is nihilistic, atheist and materialistic, suggesting that life has no meaning other than to consume. Therefore, much of the solution to poor generational relations is spiritual (see The Alt Centrist Approach To Spirituality).

A properly spiritual approach will teach people that they are all part of the natural cycle of birth, maturity and death. It would also teach people about karma, and therefore that selfishness towards the young will be reciprocated in a future life.

In a state of Nature, people incarnate into their bodies and think they are their bodies, doomed to die. Over time, some wake up and realise they are fragments of God consciousness, eternal and invincible, and that’s there’s nothing to worry about. Usually these people are old, because it takes time to wake up, which is why most of the various teachers and gurus that are well known to history are old. So in an alternative centrist state, the post-Boomer elderly would be strongly encouraged and incentivised to teach spiritual lessons to younger generations. The middle-aged and the young can deal with the material world, with business, manufacturing, retail, law enforcement etc. The elderly would be taught that they were earning a more auspicious rebirth this way.

In summary, generational relations today are coloured by the extreme selfishness and narcissism of the Boomers. The alternative centrist belief is that the following generations will be comparatively normal, and therefore generational relations will be close to normal. Once normalised, the old can be encouraged to raise the young rather than exploit them.

*

This chapter is from The Alternative Centrist Manifesto, the upcoming work of political philosophy that offers the answers to the political problems of the West.

*

If you enjoyed reading this piece, buy a compilation of our best pieces from previous years!

Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2024-25
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2023
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2022
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2021
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2020
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2019
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2018
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2017

VJMP Reads: Aristotle’s Politics V

This reading continues from here.

Book V of Politics mostly covers the causes of change or stability in constitutions.

Aristotle foreshadows the logic of Communism when he writes “People are prone to think that the fact of their being equally free-born means that they are all absolutely equal.” Lesser people find reasons to believe they deserve as much as their superiors. This is the primary cause of factionalisation: “It is the passion for equality which is thus at the root of faction.”

There are seven inherent causes of factional conflict: arrogance, profiteering, someone gets dishonoured or sees others honoured, superiority of a person or group, fear by wrongdoers expecting punishment, contempt, and a disproportionate increase of one part of the city.

In a stinging rebuke of modern Western immigration policy, Aristotle writes “Heterogeneity of stocks may lead to faction – at any rate, until they have had time to assimilate. A city cannot be constituted from any chance collection of people.” Thus it was already understood millennia ago that diversity destroys solidarity. “Most of the cities which have admitted others as settlers, either at the time of their foundation or later, have been troubled by faction.”

In fact, any person or group that adds new power to a city will tend to produce faction.

Alluding to the point made in the previous book, Aristotle notes that revolutions often occur in the absence of the moderating effect of a middle class. Treating this middle class with respect and dignity by preventing lawlessness and by not lying to them is the way to prevent constitutional collapse. Factional disputes can arise from inequality, so the middle class should be strengthened. The reasons for revolutions are unjust oppression, fear and contempt. Arrogance, especially, is the most salient form of oppression.

It’s possible to stabilise the constitution by restricting tenure of office so that more people get to have a go. The most important thing is to prevent the corrupt from profiting from holding office. Despite this emphasis on the middle class and an expanded franchise, Aristotle is no egalitarian: “Ordinary people cannot see the beginning of troubles ahead; that requires the genuine statesman.”

There are three qualifications for holders of sovereign office: loyalty to the constitution, high competence and goodness of character (including a sense of justice). This goodness of character and humility is a moderating force in politics: “Those who think that theirs is the only form of goodness, push matters to an extreme.”

Individual moral failings can also be collective moral failings: “If an individual can lack self-control, so can a city.”

Much of this book is devoted to the machinations of tyranny. Herein Aristotle distinguishes tyranny from kingship. Kings are drawn from the upper classes, from the aristoi who have distinguished themselves. Tyrants are drawn from the masses and are much baser men. “The aim of a tyrant is his own pleasure: the aim of a king is the Good.”

Of particular importance to today’s rule by globohomo, Aristotle writes “The guard of a king is comprised of citizens: that of a tyrant is composed of foreigners,” and “It is also a habit of tyrants to prefer the company of aliens to that of citizens at table and in society; citizens, they feel, are enemies, but aliens will offer no opposition.” Both of these quotes reflect the disregard that modern Western leaders have for their own peoples.

Aristotle goes into detail here about how tyrannies are preserved. One way is by the destruction of outstanding men. Another is by the destruction of men of spirit. A third is by preventing mutual confidence and high spirit by prohibiting common meals, clubs or education. A fourth is to forbid cultural societies: “use every means for making every subject as much of a stranger as is possible to every other.” A fifth is to require everyone to appear regularly in public. A sixth is to ensure nothing ever done escapes notice. A seventh is sowing mutual distrust and fostering discord between friends or classes. An eighth is impoverishing the subjects, keeping them too busy for plotting. A ninth is encouraging feminine influence.

This latter point about encouraging feminine influence is relevant to today’s Clown World. Aristotle observes that “Slaves and women are not likely to plot against tyrants: indeed, as they prosper under them, they are bound to look with favour on tyrannies and democracies alike.”

The three main ends of tyrants: to break the spirits of their subjects, to breed mutual distrust, and to make their subjects incapable of action.

*

For more of VJM’s ideas, see his work on other platforms!
For even more of VJM’s ideas, buy one of his books!

*

If you enjoyed reading this piece, buy a compilation of our best pieces from previous years!

Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2024-25
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2023
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2022
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2021
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2020
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2019
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2018
Best VJMP Essays and Articles of 2017